Claire wiped the tables a little more aggressively than usual.
If it’s not the house... then what is it?
Could it be—the world itself?
“No. It’s probably me.”31Please respect copyright.PENANASo4TCcVXe4
She muttered to herself and scrubbed harder.
But if it was just her, then why only her?31Please respect copyright.PENANAPjJVe0KNJq
Was no one else noticing this?31Please respect copyright.PENANA5R8Gu9qQea
Or were there others like her, who just... gave up looking?
“If there is someone like me, how would I even find them?”
She stood by the espresso machine, steaming milk, her brow furrowed.
Then suddenly—smack—she hit the counter.31Please respect copyright.PENANAM3GrlFZjXQ
“Wait. Tonight’s the Easter Vigil.”
If anyone knew what to do about “a tomorrow that doesn’t exist,”31Please respect copyright.PENANADdh6Tisbu1
it had to be that guy who came back to life after three days.
Jesus.
The Bible made Him sound like a full-blown sorcerer. Infinite power.31Please respect copyright.PENANAu2l57zClSn
Maybe He could help.
“If I’m extra reverent tonight, maybe tomorrow’ll finally move on.”
Claire nodded to herself, decision made.
31Please respect copyright.PENANAYDpgJYegP7
That evening, she closed up early.31Please respect copyright.PENANAqGHqnfi44G
She pan-fried two slices of ham, stuffed them into warm bagels.31Please respect copyright.PENANAoOkuRz6NyC
Brewed one cup of coffee, one of milk.31Please respect copyright.PENANA8wlizljeyk
Set them at the edge of her apartment’s balcony, just out of the wind.
The note was short:
For Nightwing and Robin.31Please respect copyright.PENANAHkXlS1Uffc
Hot food. The milk’s hotter.
P.S. Nightwing—Robin’s looking for you on Queen Street tonight.
And with that, she headed out.
31Please respect copyright.PENANA0lDXI3namb
The vigil crowd was bigger than she expected.31Please respect copyright.PENANAIfVzM6OJG4
Candles everywhere, flickering like they were breathing.
Claire sat among them, eyes closed, repeating quietly in her head:
“Please, Jesus. Help me figure out what’s wrong.”31Please respect copyright.PENANAwzfZNFqVkv
“I don’t need much. Just let tomorrow… actually happen.”31Please respect copyright.PENANAGJMzEcgjST
“Or at least… tell me what I’m supposed to do.”
Around her, people prayed, sang slow hymns.31Please respect copyright.PENANAd6gHS2rbZ6
The candlelight felt like a soft sedative.
But Claire’s mind stayed razor sharp.
She didn’t believe in God.31Please respect copyright.PENANAOiK91fskiI
But tonight, she was willing to pretend—31Please respect copyright.PENANAnkewW4OB6N
because facing an endless today alone was getting unbearable.
31Please respect copyright.PENANAqF6wZPjNrE
Midnight struck.31Please respect copyright.PENANAi69PtbSBkV
The vigil ended.
Claire walked home feeling... untethered.31Please respect copyright.PENANAio35evDYcj
Not sure if it was exhaustion or just that hollow, post-hope ache.
She climbed to the third floor, switched on the lights.31Please respect copyright.PENANAp5gaLvFxpU
Jacket off, not even halfway to the bedroom—31Please respect copyright.PENANAO4wKxWxpMx
She looked up—
Two silhouettes on the balcony.31Please respect copyright.PENANAuAQ8uORBhB
One tall. One small.31Please respect copyright.PENANAkNrQUIVNxT
Both watching her.
Nightwing. Robin.31Please respect copyright.PENANABq0NykaAEz
Outlined by the indoor light,31Please respect copyright.PENANAGV2hwBRKmf
like guardian spirits who actually kept their appointments.
Claire froze.
"...Jesus," she muttered. "I asked for help, not a pickup."
31Please respect copyright.PENANAPpetkHL8K4
Her brain stalled.31Please respect copyright.PENANAtZIY535sJ7
For a few seconds, everything just...buffered.
Then she snapped out of it, walked over, opened the window.31Please respect copyright.PENANAn4skUj4rkL
Seriously, what else was she supposed to do?31Please respect copyright.PENANAoVd10DnTBo
Leave them standing there like weird bat-themed lawn ornaments?
The two shadows hopped in with practiced ease—31Please respect copyright.PENANAc0KnB7pYhh
Same moves as last night. Copy-paste.
Nightwing opened his mouth, looked like he was struggling for an opener.
"Uh… um…"
Claire cut him off: “I’m Claire.”
He blinked, then offered a polite half-smile.31Please respect copyright.PENANA8i9NJDdbc2
“Claire. Thanks for the food, by the way.”
Robin, meanwhile, had gone full wolf cub.31Please respect copyright.PENANAjhuKXIa8OP
Eyes sharp, body tense, scanning her like she was a suspect.
“You’re the sorceress?”31Please respect copyright.PENANAPcS9oZe8CY
His voice was high-pitched, suspicious.31Please respect copyright.PENANA3R2goulAbU
“The one who talks to spirits?”
Claire frowned. “What sorceress? What spirits?”
Robin stepped closer, voice tight:31Please respect copyright.PENANAErAybFTmtO
“Then how’d you know I was on Queen Street?”
Claire blinked. Then smiled—slow, smug, maybe just a little evil.31Please respect copyright.PENANA9OeL8xRpDo
“I also knew you skipped dinner. Still hungry, right?”
Robin’s whole face crumpled, like a police dog catching a bad scent.
Nightwing quickly ruffled his hair, like calming a pet.31Please respect copyright.PENANAHtSXcj94EO
“Sorry,” he said. “We really just came to say thank you.”
Claire nodded. Didn't say a word.
Nightwing started nudging Robin toward the window.31Please respect copyright.PENANA4hLE7ZHSFE
Robin protested: “Don’t push me! I’m serious—we need to know if she’s psychic!”
Claire paused.
Something mischievous slithered up from her boots to her spine.31Please respect copyright.PENANAoPSYHEuVHL
A familiar itch.
She called out, loud and clear:31Please respect copyright.PENANAmYD7ht7NJV
“Hey!”
Both turned.
Claire tilted her head, voice calm, cryptic.31Please respect copyright.PENANA5uVhHtnhCP
“Batman’s looking for Robin. Somewhere in the city. Tonight.”
They froze.
Nightwing immediately touched his comms.31Please respect copyright.PENANAmK0UTj3wuJ
Robin snapped his head sideways, like picking up a signal.
And then—
Their eyes widened. In unison.31Please respect copyright.PENANAnGzvZRbNN1
They turned to her.
Claire grinned. That kind of grin.31Please respect copyright.PENANAVXuDNevrw0
The “gotcha” kind.
Then she stepped forward.31Please respect copyright.PENANAkGveQh8FsL
Clunk —window locked.31Please respect copyright.PENANARsG5myGgF7
Shhk —curtains drawn.31Please respect copyright.PENANANcRgNFIVxT
Clean. Final.
She stood there for a moment…31Please respect copyright.PENANAERHxEuW7rW
And then started laughing.
31Please respect copyright.PENANA8i96IKpL6R
Claire sat down and let out a long, tired breath.
She twirled her pen between her fingers, then started drafting.31Please respect copyright.PENANA2CzfmUqdRJ
There was no guarantee she’d have time tomorrow morning—31Please respect copyright.PENANA1uHoa7qKWk
or that her freaky “remember last night after a reset” skill wouldn’t just crap out again.
Better to write now. While her head was still clear.
She needed to know.31Please respect copyright.PENANAbJWP0mAIhY
Was there anyone else out there,31Please respect copyright.PENANAGFr1xr7IvG
living the same day, again and again?
At first, the letter got way too long—31Please respect copyright.PENANA5yL1WtXBIu
Like something you'd submit to a conspiracy blog with a flashing GIF header.31Please respect copyright.PENANA0SZtNqcwJv
Halfway through, she couldn’t even read her own nonsense.
Nope. Start over.
It had to hit fast.31Please respect copyright.PENANADM49JyWfiS
One glance, and the right person would know.31Please respect copyright.PENANAfoaGjN1ceM
This wasn’t a prank.31Please respect copyright.PENANAG2IyZZyavs
Wasn’t a dream.31Please respect copyright.PENANAlaDtPCDUBR
This was real.
She cut ruthlessly.31Please respect copyright.PENANAw5Tj3IDTvV
Trimmed the fluff.31Please respect copyright.PENANAj2nYHMTdMr
Boiled it down to just the facts:31Please respect copyright.PENANAr5z8LMCFms
Time’s stuck.31Please respect copyright.PENANAANjaau9EHZ
You always wake up at the same moment.31Please respect copyright.PENANAP4wCXO9Rws
No one remembers yesterday.
Then, as a final touch, she added something that read like a coded whisper:
“Have you ever felt the sun today won’t reach tomorrow?”
Yeah. That felt right.
She read the note out loud. Again. And again.31Please respect copyright.PENANAa1xKXc8aCs
It wouldn’t survive the reset. But she still wanted to remember it.31Please respect copyright.PENANATxqTQ6cp38
She wanted to remember that she’d tried.31Please respect copyright.PENANAE98ACo3Sq1
Even if no one else ever saw it—she wanted to know she hadn’t given up.
Then—
A knock on the window.
She flinched.31Please respect copyright.PENANAfP3AdodPYt
Like a nerve snapped.31Please respect copyright.PENANAEdx6mqhJeo
Froze in place.
...Again?31Please respect copyright.PENANAliAw7mUBlm
What now?31Please respect copyright.PENANAN9bSieLw0z
Was it Nightwing? The kid?
She didn’t go right away.31Please respect copyright.PENANAlEI5QjwOMt
Her eyes flicked to the note.31Please respect copyright.PENANAeV3XNeBXR5
Then to the clock.31Please respect copyright.PENANAiVYiVQikay
It was late. Way too late for casual drop-ins.
Slowly, carefully, she moved to the window.31Please respect copyright.PENANAxa91cF7X7K
Lifted one corner of the curtain.
And saw—him.
Tall.31Please respect copyright.PENANAGV2D6RdjNg
Cloaked.31Please respect copyright.PENANAtNIi7dhJ7k
Cut from shadows.31Please respect copyright.PENANAC18qIbrdat
Standing on her balcony like a statue carved from myth.
Batman.
Claire’s brain went silent.31Please respect copyright.PENANA0rVgPWhrzL
Two full seconds of white noise.
She couldn’t hear her own heartbeat.31Please respect copyright.PENANAIgmJNb6c69
Or maybe she could—so loud it drowned out everything else.
He was here.
Why?
She didn’t open the window. Not yet.31Please respect copyright.PENANAIreCqoU9om
Just stared.
At the living legend.31Please respect copyright.PENANAHkEOITpC0R
At the ghost of Gotham.